Google Notebook: A Tool for Annotation

According to one source, “… annotation means adding information (such as notes, commentary, links to source material, and so on) to existing web-accessible documents without changing the originals.”

Wikipedia defines it this way: “Annotation is extra information associated with a particular point in a document or other piece of information.”

My introduction to the term occurred when I worked for Platform Computing. While I was there, we worked on several projects whose aim was to annotate genomes.

Later on, working with Keith Aldridge of York University, I became interested in annotating data from The Global Geodynamics Project (GGP). Briefly, GGP data is collected by instruments called Superconducting Gravimeters (SGs). These instruments are incredibly sensitive to relative changes in Earth’s acceleration due to gravity. GGP is in fact a network of SGs that are distributed across the planet. Each instrument, each month provides three data files:

  • Gravity and pressure data – The primary observables sampled regularly in time
  • Auxilliary data – Complimentary observables (like groundwater levels) sampled regularly in time
  • Log data – Other observables (like service events) that occur at irregular intervals

When Keith and I first started work on introducing an XML-based data model for the GGP, we thought it made sense to automatically represent each of these files separately, and then combine them using XIncude or XSLT. (This XML-based data model is described in detail elsewhere.) After additional exposure to the XML spectrum, XPointer emerged as another option. (I alluded to this in a follow-up paper with Keith.) XML Pointer Language (XPointer) is “… the language to be used as the basis for a fragment identifier for any URI reference that locates a resource …” It’s not by coincidence that the Wikipedia definition for annotation reads similarly to this definition of XPointer from the W3C. XPointer is the W3C’s vehicle for annotation.

It’s still my take that adoption of XPointer is rather slow. For example, the only Web browser that I know of that supports annotation is the W3C’s Amaya. When browsing annotated Web pages with Amaya, clickable icons of pencils provide a link to the annotations.

The utility of annotations, taken together with the poor adoption of XPointer in mass-market Web browsers, makes for exciting possibilities for Google Notebook. What follows are a few data points on Google Notebook:

  • “Google Notebook makes web research of all kinds – from planning a vacation to researching a school paper to buying a car – easier and more efficient by enabling you to clip and gather information even while you’re browsing the web.”
  • Google Notebook lives in your Web browser
  • Google Notebook organizes, in an easily accessible way, your Web findings
  • Google Notebook is accessible from any Internetworked computer
  • Google Notebook is another prototype emerging from the Google Labs
  • Google Notebook is searchable (of course, doh!)
  • Google Notebook is publishable – click here for an example

In other words, Google Notebook is a tool for annotation!

Enthusiasm aside, I must note that:

  • Google Notebook is not standards based – I assume it’s based on proprietary Googleisms, but this requires further research (Please see the comments on this post for additional dialog on this point.)
  • Google Notebook is not a fragment identifier – The degree of granularity is the Web page itself, not a fragment on a Web page
    (Please see the comments on this post for additional dialog on this point.)
  • Google Notebook is targeted at Mozilla Firefox only – It’s enabled as a plugin (Please see the comments on this post for additional dialog on this point.)
  • Google Notebook makes use of a simple model of authentication – Username and password form the basis
  • Google Notebook doesn’t allow for Access Control Levels (ACLs) – Published notebooks are accessible by anyone who picks up on the lengthy, randomly generated URL

On balance, Google Notebook is useful, and allows for an excellent introduction to annotation. I highly recommend investigating Google Notebook, and providing your feedback to Google on it.

5 thoughts on “Google Notebook: A Tool for Annotation

  1. Hi Ian,

    When you set enthusiasm aside, you make some comments that I do not fully understand and that in some cases do not seem to me entirely accurate. But I may be wrong.

    You say “Google Notebook is not standards based.” What standards do you have in mind?

    You say “The degree of granularity is the Web page, not a fragment on a Web page.” Is this in fact true? Maybe my understanding of “granularity” is incorrect. But it seems to me that Google Notebook allows you to take only part of a Web page, by selecting it.

    You say “Google Notebook is targeted at Mozilla Firefox only.” In fact, I think it is only the Mini Notebook that is targeted at Mozilla Firefox only, via a plugin or extension. Admittedly, this is perhaps the most important function. But the implication that it cannot be used at all with any other browser is not quite accurate.

  2. Here’s my point-by-point response, David:

    Standards – XPointer is what I had in mind. I made a comment on this elsewhere.
    Granularity – My error. I have updated the original post accordingly. Thank you!
    Firefox only – Another fair point. Thank you!

  3. Pingback: Ian Lumb’s Blog » W3C Publishes New Editions of Core XML Standards

  4. Pingback: Microsoft Word: A Tool for Annotation « Ian Lumb’s Blog

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s